Trade Or Keep These NFL Quarterbacks And See If You'd Be A Good GM

The NFL Draft is right around the corner, and now that the bulk of free agency is done and over with, fans are waiting to see what additional pieces their teams will add to their roster. While many of these picks and free agent signings won't make the cut once the regular season comes around, there is still an air of excitement, and these men now have the chance to make their dreams come true. The NFL Draft will see a number of quarterbacks taken with high picks, and they will look to show the NFL that they are prepared to take the league into a new era,

The quarterbacks that are currently on NFL rosters would love nothing more than to lead their team to a Super Bowl, and while football is a team sport, there is no denying that quarterbacks get the bulk of the love from people. The best in the game have a Super Bowl to their name, and the rest of the bunch will be looking to get their first by the time the 2019 season comes to an end.

Today, we are going to see how prospective GMs will handle these quarterbacks, revealing their true acumen in the process.

Question 1

Trade or Keep Kirk Cousins

After making his way to the Minnesota Vikings, people were convinced that this man was going to be the one to lead them back to the Super Bowl. Things did not work out during his first season with the Vikings, and now he will have to go out and prove that he was worth his gigantic contract in the 2019 season. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 2

Trade or Keep Alex Smith

This man has suited up for several teams during his time in the NFL, and after undergoing some serious health issues in 2018, it is quite possible that he has played his last snap. He came to Washington after the team parted ways with Kirk Cousins, and it appears as though the team will need to plug some more holes at the position. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 3

Trade or Keep Ryan Tannehill

Having started his journey with the Miami Dolphins, it seemed like each season began with people proclaiming that this was the year that this man would ascend to the top of the quarterback ranks. Unfortunately, this never truly happened, and after several years in South Beach, the team decided to ship this man off to Tennessee to play behind their starter. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 4

Trade or Keep Sam Darnold

Being taken with a high pick in the NFL Draft means that a player will have to come in and play at a high level immediately, and there were some genuinely great moments during this man’s rookie season. While it wasn’t what the Jets were hoping for, they made sure to add some solid pieces recently to ensure that this man gets the help that he needs. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 5

Trade or Keep Blaine Gabbert

After being taken by the Jaguars in the first round of the NFL Draft some years back, this man did not quite live up to expectations in Duval, and he has seen his NFL journey take stops in other cities. He is someone that has amassed a great deal of experience in the league, and he can provide a younger player with some guidance and leadership at practice during the week. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 6

Trade or Keep Josh Dobbs

There were moments in college when it seemed like this player would be able to excel at the next level, but as we have seen thus far, he is typically relegated to riding the pine pony and managing from the sidelines. The fact that he has been able to make it on NFL rosters proves that he has potential, and he can provide a team with a decent insurance policy as well. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 7

Trade or Keep Lamar Jackson

Initially beginning his inaugural campaign sitting behind Joe Flacco, fans were interested in seeing how long it would be before this player got his chance to make waves on the field. Once he was plugged in as the starter, new life was breathed into the team, and they were able to become a dominant team on the ground. He is their starter as they head into 2019. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 8

Trade or Keep Blake Bortles

Taken ahead of players like Khalil Mack and Aaron Donald in the 2014 NFL Draft meant that this player had to become a star in a hurry, and his tenure in Jacksonville was met with some highs and lows along the way. The team decided to part ways with him recently, and he was able to secure a spot out in Los Angeles to play behind the Rams starting quarterback. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 9

Trade or Keep Nick Mullens

Players like this man here aren’t even expected to make an NFL roster, and this player was able to secure a spot in San Francisco and lay a complete and total shellacking on the Raiders during his first start in the NFL. Things were up and down after that, but he was able to prove to people that he deserves to have a place on an NFL roster. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 10

Trade or Keep Drew Brees

As a bona fide Hall of Fame player and someone that is one of the best to ever suit up, this man has nothing left to prove, yet he still continues to put on a master class each Sunday during the NFL season. He has seen and done it all, and because he is one of the more likable guys around, fans would love to see him take home one more Super Bowl. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 11

Trade or Keep Mitch Trubisky

A player’s rookie season does not define them, which is a good thing, because this man’s rookie campaign was a rather forgettable one. Instead of tucking his tail between his legs, he went out in his sophomore season and showed marked improvement, and the Bears look to be a serious contender out in the NFC. He should take some more positive strides in his third year. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 12

Trade or Keep Sam Bradford

Looking back at how things turned out, some may be surprised that this man was a top pick in the NFL Draft, but it is important to keep in mind how health issues have derailed his entire run. He was an incredible prospect back in college, but his inability to remain on the field at the next level is something that cost him a ton of playing time. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 13

Trade or Keep Russell Wilson

This man has been one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL for quite some time, and with a slew of accolades and a Super Bowl win under his belt, he is someone that could very well be staring at the doors of Canton when it is all said and done. He is a huge reason why the Seahawks continue to be solid, and with the right pieces, they could be a great team once again. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 14

Trade or Keep Nick Foles

There are few stories in the NFL quite like this one here, and now that he secured the bag with the Jaguars, people will be looking closely as he tries to bring the Jags to the next level. He is a Super Bowl winner and a Super Bowl MVP, but his time in the NFL has been wildly inconsistent. If he hits his stride in Jacksonville, they are going to be a force in the AFC. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 15

Trade or Keep Derek Anderson

It seemed like this man was done with it all and on to the next phase of his life when he was suddenly brought back into the NFL last season. He is the man that was at the helm the last time the Browns made it into the playoffs, and he has a wealth of experience behind him. He can play ball, but he is primarily used as someone to provide guidance on the sidelines. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 16

Trade or Keep Brandon Weeden

Rare is it to see someone in the latter part of their 20s make it into the NFL as a rookie, but this is precisely what happened when this player came into the league. He is a player that has been able to stick around for a solid amount of time, and even though no one will mistake him for Joe Montana, he can still be a decent insurance policy for any franchise. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 17

Trade or Keep Patrick Mahomes

Let’s be honest, there is absolutely no way that any person could have predicted the type of season that this man would have in 2018, and after winning NFL MVP and throwing for over 5,000 yards and 50 touchdowns in just his second season, the sky is the absolute limit for this player here. The rest of the AFC West has to play this man twice a season. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 18

Trade or Keep Dak Prescott

As a mid-round selection, this man was supposed to sit behind Tony Romo and learn the ropes, but once Romo went down, he stepped up and has been among the winningest quarterbacks in the NFL ever since. He has been able to take advantage of his line help and running back play, and his ability to extend plays has been instrumental in his success. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 19

Trade or Keep Geno Smith

This player came into the NFL Draft during a year in which no quarterback prospect was deemed a sure thing, and as one of the top quarterback prospects taken, he as expected to be one of the best ones in the class. He has had some moments to start in the league, but he has not been able to lock down a long term spot as a franchise quarterback on any team. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 20

Trade or Keep Joe Flacco

After having an elite run in the playoffs when he was a younger player, this man was able to secure a huge contract and be the leader of the Ravens for a number of years. Now that a youth injection has taken over the team, this man has made his way out to Denver to lead the charge for the Broncos. That is, of course, unless they draft a quarterback early on. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 21

Trade or Keep Josh McCown

This man has suited up for a ton of teams during his time in the league, and he has been able to do some solid things while coming in and filling a need off the bench. Some of his best play came during his time with the Chicago Bears, and he was recently a mentor to quarterback Sam Darnold. While he would love to start somewhere, he will gladly mentor younger players. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 22

Trade or Keep Mike Glennon

This player has played for several teams during his time in the league, and it seems like each team he plays for winds up taking a young player to usurp him down the line. His most recent stints have been with the Bears and the Cardinals, and the Raiders swooped him up recently. He will sit behind their starter, assuming the team does not take a quarterback in the NFL Draft. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 23

Trade or Keep Andrew Luck

After missing a substantial amount of time, people were wondering how this player would hold up as he made his way back onto the field. Turns out, he picked up where he left off, and he was slinging the ball like he did when he first came into the league. He will be looking to take another step in 2019, and he will be a huge reason why the Colts are a contender in the AFC. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 24

Trade or Keep Nathan Peterman

The Buffalo Bills made the decision to stick this man on the field instead of Tyrod Taylor back in 2017, and things could not have gone any worse. He had some chances to take the field in 2018, but things did not work out, and he was exiled from Buffalo. He is currently on the Raiders practice squad looking to make the team. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 25

Trade or Keep Matt Ryan

As a former NFL MVP, people know that this man can completely dominate a game, and after a down year in 2018, fans are interested in seeing how he and the Falcons will bounce back in 2019. When he is on fire, he is nearly unstoppable on the field, and the Falcons can do some solid things if things fall in the right places before the season gets underway. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 26

Trade or Keep Aaron Rogers

The Green Bay Packers are going to look like a completely different team this year, and many are hopeful that shaking things up will be just what this player needs to take his team back to the Super Bowl. It was clear that things weren’t working with his former coach, and the new man in charge will need to do what he can to put them in a position to succeed. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 27

Trade or Keep Josh Rosen

The Arizona Cardinals took this man in the 2018 NFL Draft with the hopes that he could be their franchise quarterback, but after just one year, rumors are swirling that he will be traded in favor of another quarterback prospect. He flashed potential at UCLA, and the coach and team around him did him little favors during his first NFL season. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 28

Trade or Keep Case Keenum

After a miracle year in Minnesota, this player made his way to the Broncos to settle down their quarterback carousel, but instead of galvanizing the offense, he struggled, and the team has decided to move on from him already. He has a ton of arm talent, and a change of scenery could be beneficial for him. His 2017 season remains the best he has had. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 29

Trade or Keep Andy Dalton

A wind of change has blown through Cincinnati, and that could spell the end of this man’s time under center for the team. He has led them to the playoffs in the past and has done some solid things, but he has never been better than “good”. Should he finish out the 2019 season with the Bengals, it is possible that they could cut ties or trade this man. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 30

Trade or Keep Josh Allen

With a huge arm and a massive upside, the Buffalo Bills swooped up this player in the 2018 NFL Draft, and after doing more with his feet than his arm, the team is hoping that he can take the next step in 2019. The team as a whole was not up to snuff last year, and if they want to improve and reach the playoffs again, then this man needs some help. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 31

Trade or Keep Matthew Stafford

The Lions did not live up to expectations last year, and many were beginning to wonder how much time this player had left on the team. He is someone that can always hang up incredible statistics, but his record against winning teams leaves a lot to be desired. Of course, the Lions are almost never great, so maybe going to another team could help. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 32

Trade or Keep Jameis Winston

Coming out of Florida State, this player was expected to become the next great franchise quarterback in the NFL, especially with a Heisman to his name. He has flashed at times since coming into the league in 2015, but his inconsistent play has led him to being benched multiple times, and the Buccaneers have a decision to make about him next year. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 33

Trade or Keep Marcus Mariota

After being one of the best quarterbacks in the nation during his time at Oregon, the Titans were more than happy to make this player their future, and while they have reached the playoffs with him at the helm, they have yet to cross over into the elite of the NFL. Once this season is up, the team will have a huge choice to make about this player. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 34

Trade or Keep Deshaun Watson

Rookie seasons can often be misleading for players around the league, and Texans fans were hoping that this man’s rookie season wasn’t just going to be a flash in the pan. During his sophomore season, he was able to do some incredible things on the field, and the Texans appear to have someone that can be a legitimate franchise quarterback finally. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 35

Trade or Keep Ryan Fitzpatrick

The first few games of the 2018 season saw this man playing at an MVP level, and people thought the that Harvard alum had finally hit the big time. Instead, things would taper off eventually, though it was fun while it lasted. He has been on several teams during his time in the league, and he was recently signed by the Dolphins to give them a boost on offense. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 36

Trade or Keep C.J. Beathard

The San Francisco 49ers gave this man the chance to become a franchise player, but after being unable to impress their front office, they brought in a kid from New England and sat this man down to learn and lead from afar. He was thrust onto the field in 2018, though he would eventually go down with health issues as the season went on. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 37

Trade or Keep Cam Newton

With a Heisman to his name and an NFL MVP to boot, this man’s time playing the sport of football has been a fruitful one, and the Panthers have been happy to have him as their leader on the field. He is someone that has taken the running element of the position to heights never reached, and he has the arm talent to make teams pay for overcommitting to the run. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 38

Trade or Keep Jared Goff

If players were given contracts after their rookie seasons, then this man would have never played another down in the NFL. His rookie season was the talk of the league, but since then, he has turned into one of the best young quarterbacks in the game, and he was in the running for MVP for most of 2018. He would eventually lead the Rams to the Super Bowl. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 39

Trade or Keep Carson Wentz

If this man can stay healthy and on the field, then he is going to take home an NFL MVP one day. The last two seasons for him have ended prematurely, and the Eagles decided that his upside weighed far more than his inability to remain healthy for an entire NFL campaign. With Nick Foles gone, this player will have a lot to prove in the 2019 season. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 40

Trade or Keep Brock Osweiler

The Denver Broncos winning the Super Bowl a few years back was largely attributed to their defense, but this man’s play during that season led him to cashing in on a massive contract from the Texans. Unfortunately, things did not work out there, and he has since bounced around the league, with a recent stop playing for the Miami Dolphins. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 41

Trade or Keep Jimmy Garoppolo

Playing for the New England Patriots means that a player is going to win a lot, and after winning some games while filling in for Tom Brady, this player was shipped out to San Francisco, where he led the team to several straight wins. The franchise rewarded him with a gigantic contract, and the following season, he went down with a tear and missed the majority of the year. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 42

Trade or Keep Baker Mayfield

Polarizing hardly begins to describe this player here, and after the Browns made him the top pick in the NFL Draft, he was going to have to prove the world wrong. Once the right coach took over, he would begin to play at a high level, and with some reinforcements coming in, the Browns appear to be legitimate contenders heading into 2019. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 43

Trade or Keep Tom Brady

This man is the greatest quarterback to ever step onto a football field, and we are past the point of this being a debate. He has now won 6 Super Bowls, and he is in the top 5 of nearly every major statistical category for quarterbacks. Even though he is turning 42 later this year, he remains one of the best around, so we should enjoy his play while we still can. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 44

Trade or Keep Derek Carr

The Oakland Raiders have been a mess since going 12-4 back in 2016, and it was during that season that this man was in the running for an NFL MVP. It was also the only point during his run that he has had the same coordinator for more than one year. 2019 will mark only the second time this has happened, and the team has given him Antonio Brown and Tyrell Williams to work with. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 45

Trade or Keep Eli Manning

Many people cannot believe that the New York Giants did not take a quarterback in last year’s draft, especially considering the diminishing play of this man here. He has taken home 2 Super MVPs during his time in the league, though at this point, many people believe that the Giants need to find their quarterback of the future sooner rather than later. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 46

Trade or Keep Trevor Siemian

Players coming into the league all look to find a spot on a roster, and despite being taken in a place where few people succeed, this man was able to become a starter for the Denver Broncos. He did enough to lock down a spot in the league during his time in Denver, and he was recently picked up by the Jets as an insurance policy moving forward. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 47

Trade or Keep Ben Roethlisberger

When it is all said and done, this player will be enshrined in the Hall of Fame alongside other greats from Pittsburgh’s past. He has brought the Steel City multiple wins in the Super Bowl, and he will finish with incredible numbers in major statistical categories. He has publicly mulled retirement, so no one truly knows how much time he has left on the field. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 48

Trade or Keep Philip Rivers

As one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history to never play in a Super Bowl, the debate will wage on about this man’s place in the Hall of Fame. Sure, he has the numbers to get in, but he also plays in an era where stats are inflated compared to the past. Should he pump out a few more great years with a Super Bowl appearance, then he is a lock to make it. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 49

Trade or Keep A.J. McCarron

Playing at Alabama means that a player gets used to winning at the collegiate level, and they will get opportunities to shine in the NFL. This player got his start with the Bengals, showing some promise once their starter went down. He headed to Buffalo for a chance to start, but was sat on the bench. He spent last season in Oakland, and he will be in Houston in 2019. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

Question 50

Trade or Keep Matt Barkley

There was a ton of hype around this player when he was coming out of high school, and after a decent time at the collegiate level, he was brought into the NFL with the hopes that he could develop his overall game. He has done some decent things during his time in the league, but he has yet to show that he can be a franchise quarterback for the long haul. Any GM wanting to make some waves in the NFL will know exactly what to do with this quarterback here. (Pro Football Reference)

See Your Result
Questions Left